Skip to content
Evergreen Counseling and Consulting

Blog

Purity Culture and Trauma: How Religious Teachings About Sex Can Cause Lasting Harm

November 16, 2026 · by Heather, EMDRIA Certified EMDR Therapist

Can religious teachings about sex actually cause trauma? Yes. Purity culture, the sexual ethic rooted in Evangelical Christianity that emphasizes abstinence before marriage and places the burden of purity disproportionately on women and girls, can create psychological harm that shows up in your relationships, your sense of self, and your body. Research shows that exposure to purity culture beliefs is linked to sexual shame, sexual pain, lower relationship satisfaction, and symptoms that mirror those of sexual trauma, even when no assault occurred (Sawatsky et al., 2024; Coates & Meston, 2026).

What Is Purity Culture?

Purity culture is a set of teachings and practices common in conservative Christian communities that frame sexuality as something inherently dangerous that must be rigidly controlled. At its core, purity culture teaches that sexual activity outside of heterosexual marriage is sinful, that desire itself is suspect, and that purity (defined as virginity or sexual abstinence) is the highest virtue, especially for women.

You might have encountered purity culture through purity rings, abstinence pledges, modesty teachings, courtship instead of dating, books like I Kissed Dating Goodbye, or sermons that compared people who have sex outside marriage to used chewing gum, torn tape, or damaged goods. The language varies, but the message is consistent: your worth is tied to your sexual purity, and once you lose it, you're fundamentally diminished.

A 2023 study developed a measurement tool for purity culture beliefs and found that these teachings cluster around sexually restrictive messages (no sex before marriage, purity as the ideal) and sexually coercive messages (women are responsible for men's lust, modest dress is required to prevent sin) (Ortiz et al., 2023).

Why Does Purity Culture Cause Trauma for Some People?

Trauma happens when an experience overwhelms your capacity to cope and leaves lasting changes in how you see yourself, your body, or the world. Purity culture can be traumatic because it teaches shame about natural human development, creates fear around normal desires, and links your moral worth to something you can't always control.

For people raised in purity culture, the teachings often begin in childhood, before you have the developmental capacity to critically evaluate what you're being told. You internalize the message that parts of you are dangerous or sinful, and that shame becomes part of your identity.

If you experienced sexual abuse or assault, purity culture can compound the trauma. Research shows that childhood exposure to purity culture is associated with greater sexual shame for survivors of sexual abuse, contributing to sexual shame above and beyond the impact of the abuse itself (Coates & Meston, 2026). Survivors in purity culture environments often blame themselves for what happened, believing they somehow caused the abuse through immodesty, impure thoughts, or not being vigilant enough.

Even without assault, purity culture can feel traumatic. When you're taught that your body has the power to make others sin, or that any sexual thought or feeling makes you impure, it creates a no-win situation. You're hypervigilant about your own desires and your body's responses, which is exhausting and isolating.

What Are the Signs That Purity Culture Has Affected You?

Purity culture's impact shows up in several areas. If you grew up in these teachings, you might recognize some of these patterns. Many of these signs overlap with the broader signs of religious trauma, but purity culture creates specific harm around sexuality, bodies, and intimate relationships.

How Does It Affect Sexual Health and Intimacy?

Research found that belief in purity culture tropes is associated with higher rates of sexual pain disorders, lower marital satisfaction, and lower sexual satisfaction (Sawatsky et al., 2024). When you've been taught that sex is shameful or dangerous, your body doesn't just forget that message when you get married. The shame persists.

Some people describe an inability to enjoy sex even in contexts their faith community would approve of, like marriage. The years of conditioning that said sex is wrong don't reverse overnight. Others experience pain during sex with no clear physical cause, which clinicians increasingly recognize as a potential trauma response.

You might struggle with desire itself, feeling guilty or broken for wanting intimacy. Or you might dissociate during sex, emotionally checking out as a way to cope with the dissonance between what you've been taught and what you're experiencing.

What Emotional and Psychological Impacts Are Common?

Sexual shame is one of the most consistent findings in purity culture research. Both childhood exposure to and adult acceptance of purity culture beliefs predict higher sexual shame, particularly for people who have survived sexual violence (Coates & Meston, 2026).

Shame about your body, your desires, and your sexual history can create chronic anxiety, depression, and a negative sense of self. You might feel like you're fundamentally flawed or broken, especially if you didn't live up to the purity ideal.

Perfectionism is another common pattern. When your worth is tied to maintaining an impossible standard, any perceived failure feels catastrophic. Some people describe a binary mindset: once they violated a purity teaching, they felt like there was no point in having boundaries at all, which left them vulnerable to further harm.

How Does It Show Up in Relationships?

Purity culture can make it hard to build healthy intimate relationships. If you were taught that desire is dangerous and that physical affection is a slippery slope, you might struggle to know what healthy boundaries look like. Some people swing between rigid control and no boundaries at all because the middle ground was never modeled.

Trust can be difficult. When you've internalized the message that men only want one thing or that women are manipulative, it's hard to show up authentically in a relationship. You might also have difficulty communicating your needs, especially sexual needs, because you were never taught that your desires matter.

For LGBTQ+ people raised in purity culture, the harm is often compounded. Research examining the impact of purity culture on sexual and gender minority people found that purity culture creates patriarchal, heteronormative structures that erase and condemn any expression of sexuality or gender identity outside a narrow norm (Muskrat et al., 2025). The shame, the hiding, and the message that who you are is fundamentally sinful can create deep trauma.

What Physical Symptoms Can Purity Culture Trauma Cause?

Trauma lives in the body, and purity culture trauma is no exception. Some people experience chronic pelvic pain, painful sex (vaginismus or dyspareunia), tension in the jaw or shoulders, or digestive issues with no clear medical cause.

Hypervigilance about your body is another sign. You might be constantly monitoring what you're wearing, how you're sitting, or whether you're drawing attention in ways that could be considered immodest. That chronic self-surveillance is exhausting and keeps your nervous system on high alert.

What If You Didn't Think It Affected You Until Now?

It's common not to recognize purity culture's impact until years later. When you're still inside the belief system, the harm is normalized. It's only when you start to question the teachings, or when you encounter a different framework for understanding sexuality and bodies, that the dissonance becomes clear.

Some people don't realize they've been harmed until they try to have sex in a context their community would approve of, like marriage, and find they can't relax or enjoy it. Others notice the impact when they have children and realize they don't want to pass the same teachings on.

The fact that you're recognizing it now doesn't mean you were overreacting before. It means you have more information and more distance, and you can see the patterns for what they are.

Can You Heal From Purity Culture Trauma?

Yes. Healing from purity culture trauma is possible, though it takes time and often requires support from someone who understands the specific nature of this harm.

Therapy helps, especially trauma-focused approaches like EMDR, which can help you reprocess the shame and fear associated with the teachings. Research on survivors' experiences found that trauma-focused therapy was particularly helpful when therapists understood purity culture and took it seriously as a source of harm (Coates & Meston, 2026).

One challenge many people face is finding a therapist who understands purity culture. Some therapists, especially those who haven't encountered these teachings themselves, can be inadvertently dismissive or minimize the impact. If your therapist doesn't get why this matters, it's okay to find someone who does.

Part of healing involves rebuilding your relationship with your body. That might mean learning to listen to your body's signals instead of overriding them, practicing self-compassion, or exploring what desire and pleasure feel like without the overlay of shame.

Another piece is rebuilding your sense of self outside of the purity framework. Who are you when your worth isn't tied to your sexual history? What do you actually believe about bodies, desire, and relationships when you're not simply reacting against what you were taught or clinging to it?

For many people, healing also involves grieving. You might grieve the experiences you didn't get to have, the relationships that were damaged, the parts of yourself you had to hide, or the years spent believing you were fundamentally flawed.

What If You're Still in a Purity Culture Environment?

If you're still part of a religious community that teaches purity culture, healing is more complicated but not impossible. You might not be able to leave for practical, relational, or spiritual reasons, and that's okay.

You can still work on disentangling your worth from your sexual history, challenging the beliefs that cause you the most harm, and finding spaces (even if they're online or private) where you can process what you're experiencing.

Some people find it helpful to distinguish between their faith and the purity culture teachings. Many progressive Christian, Jewish, and other religious communities have reframed sexuality in ways that affirm bodies, desire, and diverse expressions of intimacy. If your faith is important to you, you don't necessarily have to leave it behind to heal from purity culture. You might need to find a different expression of that faith.

How Can You Support Someone Healing From Purity Culture?

If someone you care about is healing from purity culture trauma, the most important thing you can do is believe them. Don't minimize the harm or suggest that they're overreacting because the teachings seem benign to you.

Understand that shame about sexuality runs deep, and it doesn't resolve quickly. Be patient if they struggle with intimacy, have strong reactions to religious imagery, or need to process their experiences repeatedly.

Don't pressure them to forgive the people or institutions that harmed them before they're ready. Healing happens on its own timeline, and forgiveness, if it comes, is theirs to offer when and if they choose.

You Deserve to Heal

Purity culture trauma is real, and it's not your fault. You didn't choose to internalize those teachings, and the harm they caused is not a sign that you're broken or weak. It's a sign that you were taught shame about parts of yourself that were never shameful to begin with.

Healing means reclaiming your body, your desires, and your sense of self from teachings that never served you. It means learning that your worth isn't tied to what you've done or haven't done sexually, and that you get to decide what healthy sexuality and intimacy look like for you.

If you're in Georgia, Pennsylvania, or Florida and you're ready to work through the harm purity culture caused, I'd be honored to walk that path with you. I'm a therapist and theologian, and I understand both the spiritual weight of religious trauma and the therapeutic work it takes to heal. I work with religious and spiritual trauma using EMDR, IFS, and other trauma-focused approaches, all by video. When you're ready, get in touch. I can't wait to hear from you!

References

Coates, T. N., & Meston, C. M. (2026). Being pure and being ashamed: Purity culture and sexual shame among survivors of nonconsensual sexual experiences. Journal of Sex Research. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00224499.2026.2653785

Muskrat, T. Y., Porcaro, A. K., Worley, M. G., Franco, A. E., Parmenter, J. G., & Sánchez, F. J. (2025). "Being yourself is a sin": The impact of evangelical purity culture on sexual and gender minority people socialized as women. The Counseling Psychologist, 53(5), 672–699. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00110000251352578

Ortiz, A. M., Sunu, B. C., Hall, M. E. L., Anderson, T. L., & Wang, D. C. (2023). Purity culture: Measurement and relationship to domestic violence myth acceptance. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 51(4), 476–492. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00916471231182734

Sawatsky, J., Lindenbach, R., Gregoire, S. W., & Gregoire, K. (2024). Sanctified sexism: Effects of purity culture tropes on white Christian women's marital and sexual satisfaction and experience of sexual pain. Sociology of Religion, 86(4), 519–543. https://academic.oup.com/socrel/article-abstract/86/4/519/7863400

More about EMDR therapy online and virtual EMDR intensives.

If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), call 911, or go to your nearest emergency room.

I can't wait to hear from you!

If any of this resonates with you, I'd love to connect! Send a note through the contact form or by email.

Get in touch

If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), call 911, or go to your nearest emergency room.